← CFB HubCaptain & Value picks

The Saturday Shortlist, Week 12

The week's 25 best captain options and 25 best values, ranked from each game's data, with links to the game previews.

25 captain picks · 25 value picks

One score for each player: his production (his last three games, his season and his two best games, with his role’s trend), adjusted for the defense he faces at his position, from 15 percent down against the toughest to 15 percent up against the softest, and 10 percent off for a Group of 6 player facing a Power 4 defense in the top half at his position. The projection only breaks ties.

1Easton Messer WRStarted
Florida Atlantic vs. South Florida · Sat, Nov. 21 · 2:30 PM ET · $15.1M

He has scored 2 touchdowns a game on 1 red-zone look a game, up from 1.1 on 1.1, and Florida Atlantic has thrown on 65 percent of its plays, up from 55. He has a 60.0-point high this season and has averaged 35.9 points over his last three games, up from 29.6 for the season.

Read the preview →
2Marcus Stokes QBStarted
Memphis at Navy · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $8.7M

He has averaged 41.2 points in his last three games, up from 27.4 for the season. He also has a 43.8-point high this season.

Read the preview →
3Jackson Gutierrez QBStarted
Navy vs. Memphis · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $7.4M

His season high is 55.1 points. He has run for 173 yards a game across his last three games, with 112 passing and has averaged 41.7 points in that stretch, up from 32.1 for the season.

Read the preview →
4Caleb Hawkins RBStarted
Oklahoma State at Arizona State · Sat, Nov. 21 · 10:15 PM ET · $14.9M

He has a 54.6-point game on his record this season. He has also averaged 42.8 points over his last three games, up from 26.8 for the season.

Read the preview →
5Rasean Jones WRStarted
Boise State vs. San Diego State · Sat, Nov. 21 · 9:30 PM ET · $7.5M

38.4 points a game in his last three games, up from 22.2 for the season. He has a 52.9-point high this season and has gone from 26% to 32% of Boise State's targets.

Read the preview →
6Nate Sheppard RBStarted
Duke vs. Clemson · Fri, Nov. 20 · 7:30 PM ET · $13.4M

Across his last three games, he has averaged 44.0 points, up from 35.8 for the season. He also gets 61% of Duke's carries.

Read the preview →
7Michael Hawkins QBStarted
West Virginia vs. Houston · Sat, Nov. 21 · 1:00 PM ET · $10.1M

He has already put up 50.3 points in a game this season. He has run for 70 yards a game over his last three games, with 203 passing.

Read the preview →
8Aiden Flora RBStarted
Iowa State at UCF · Fri, Nov. 20 · 6:00 PM ET · $7.1M

Iowa State has scored 5 offensive touchdowns a game, up from 2.5, and he has had 77 percent of Iowa State's running-back work inside the 20, up from 44. He has also averaged 37.1 points in his last three games, up from 25.4 for the season and has a 49.1-point high this season.

Read the preview →
9Wayne Harris WRStarted
Kent State vs. Miami (OH) · Tue, Nov. 17 · 7:00 PM ET · $7.4M

His work rose in games Da'Realyst Clark missed or played only part of (Weeks 8 and 9), and it has held with Clark back. He faces the worst defense against wide receivers in FBS and has averaged 32.7 points across his last three games, up from 16.9 for the season.

Read the preview →
10Micah Ford RBStarted
Stanford at California · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.6M

His share of Stanford's carries is up to 68%, from 56%. He also has a 52.1-point high this season and faces the 15th-worst defense against running backs in FBS.

Read the preview →
11Jahiem White RBStarted
North Texas at Tulane · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $13.0M

He now gets 57% of North Texas' carries, up from 49%. He has averaged 25.5 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
13Jeremiah Smith WRStarted
Ohio State at Nebraska · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $16.8M

He has a 57.7-point game on his record this season. He gets 34% of Ohio State's targets and faces the 12th-best defense against wide receivers in FBS.

Read the preview →
14Jesse Legree WRStarted
Oregon State vs. Utah State · Sat, Nov. 21 · 10:30 PM ET · $8.4M

29% of Oregon State's targets now go to him, up from 23%. He also has a 47.1-point high this season.

Read the preview →
16Oran Singleton WRStarted
Tulsa vs. Charlotte · Sat, Nov. 21 · 2:00 PM ET · $7.2M

His targets rose to 10 a game, from 4.3, and Tulsa's receivers have scored 61 percent of its touchdowns, up from 36 percent. He also faces the fifth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

The game →
18Conner Weigman QBStarted
Houston at West Virginia · Sat, Nov. 21 · 1:00 PM ET · $12.0M

He faces the second-worst pass defense in FBS. He has also thrown for 260 yards a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
19Darian Mensah QBStarted
Miami vs. Virginia Tech · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:00 PM ET · $12.6M

He has thrown for 311 yards a game over his last three games. He has averaged 23.5 points in that stretch.

Read the preview →
22Messiah Burch RBStarted
Buffalo vs. Central Michigan · Wed, Nov. 18 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.6M

His carries rose to 22.5 a game, from 9. He has also averaged 25.0 points over his last three games, up from 16.0 for the season.

The game →
23Koby Howard WRQuestionableStarted
Penn State vs. Rutgers · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.5M

This week he draws the 13th-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS. He has a 28.5-point high this season.

The game →
24Cole Tabb RBStarted
Cincinnati vs. Colorado · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.7M

His share of Cincinnati's carries is up to 37%, from 24%. He also has a 38.9-point high this season.

Read the preview →
25Jemyri Davis WRStarted
Memphis at Navy · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.7M

His matchup: the eighth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS. He got 18% of Memphis' targets in games Jermane Hayes played only part of, up from 12%.

The game →

Points for the price, measured against his position’s typical value, so a tight end is compared with tight ends. Players within about 10 percent of each other share a tier, and the softer matchup goes first inside it. $7.0M or under; at most six quarterbacks; the projection only breaks ties.

1Jelani Thurman TEStarted
North Carolina at Virginia · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:30 PM ET · $5.5M

$5.5M for 20.5 points a game over his last three games. He has a 25.4-point high this season.

The game →
2Kari Ashley TEStarted
TCU vs. Utah · Sat, Nov. 21 · 9:00 PM ET · $5.5M

At $5.5M, he has scored 16.0 points a game in his last three games. He also has a 30.9-point high this season and got 28% of TCU's targets in games Ed Small played only part of, up from 19%.

Read the preview →
3Koby Howard WRQuestionableStarted
Penn State vs. Rutgers · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.5M

22.3 points a game across his last three games, at a price of $5.5M. He faces the 13th-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

The game →
4Micah Ford RBStarted
Stanford at California · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.6M

His season high is 52.1 points. At $6.6M, he has scored 27.3 points a game over his last three games. He has also gone from 56% to 68% of Stanford's carries.

Read the preview →
5Chance Morrow WRStarted
Buffalo vs. Central Michigan · Wed, Nov. 18 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.5M

He has a 43.9-point game on his record this season. He costs $6.5M and has averaged 20.1 points in his last three games. He also gets 33% of Buffalo's targets.

The game →
6Isaiah Mizell WRStarted
Arizona at Kansas State · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:00 PM ET · $6.4M

His earlier numbers came in games Giovanni Richardson missed or played only part of (Weeks 3, 4 and 5); with both healthy, Richardson had 24 catches to his 20; his targets rose to 9 a game, from 5.7. For $6.4M, he has put up 27.4 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 36.3-point high this season.

Read the preview →
7Cole Tabb RBStarted
Cincinnati vs. Colorado · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.7M

His share of Cincinnati's carries is up to 37%, from 24%. At $6.7M, he has scored 24.5 points a game over his last three games.

Read the preview →
8Chris Lawson WRStarted
Washington vs. Indiana · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.8M

At $5.8M, he has scored 25.5 points a game in his last three games. He also faces the sixth-best defense against wide receivers in FBS and got 31% of Washington's targets in games Jordan Clay missed or played only part of, up from 18%.

Read the preview →
9Jackson Harris WRStarted
LSU at Tennessee · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $7.0M

His targets rose to 10.8 a game, from 4.6, and he has had 32 percent of LSU's receiving work inside the 20, up from 6. For $7.0M, he has put up 30.9 points a game across his last three games. He also faces the best defense against wide receivers in FBS.

Read the preview →
10Patrick Overmyer TEStarted
Houston at West Virginia · Sat, Nov. 21 · 1:00 PM ET · $7.0M

He has already put up 40.4 points in a game this season. At $7.0M, he has scored 12.7 points a game over his last three games. He also faces the second-worst pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
11Jemyri Davis WRStarted
Memphis at Navy · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.7M

He faces the eighth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS. He costs $5.7M and has averaged 25.6 points in his last three games.

The game →
12Kemper Hodges QBStarted
Air Force vs. UTEP · Fri, Nov. 20 · 8:00 PM ET · $5.6M

This week he draws the third-worst pass defense in FBS. For $5.6M, he has put up 28.5 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
13Gael Ochoa QBStarted
Rice at Temple · Thu, Nov. 19 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.2M

Gael Ochoa started Weeks 10 and 11 while Jacurri Brown was injured and averaged 13.5 points a game. Brown averaged 16 in his five starts. Brown is not on the injury report this week. At $5.2M, he has scored 28.1 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 57.1-point high this season.

Read the preview →
14Messiah Burch RBStarted
Buffalo vs. Central Michigan · Wed, Nov. 18 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.6M

His carries rose to 22.5 a game, from 9. He costs $6.6M and has averaged 25.0 points in his last three games.

The game →
15Calvin Russell WRStarted
Syracuse at Boston College · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.6M

His season high is 39.1 points. For $5.6M, he has put up 19.9 points a game across his last three games. He got 30% of Syracuse's targets in games Umari Hatcher played only part of, up from 21%.

The game →
16A'Marion Peterson RBStarted
UTSA at UAB · Sat, Nov. 21 · 8:00 PM ET · $6.4M

He has had 56 percent of UTSA's running-back work inside the 20, up from 35, and he has run for 10.6 yards a carry, up from 6.7. At $6.4M, he has scored 24.0 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 41.9-point high this season. Touchdowns are 56 percent of his points, and his yards and catches are worth 7.5 points a game.

Read the preview →
17Luke Dehnicke TEStarted
Northwestern at Minnesota · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.1M

At $5.1M, he has scored 12.4 points a game in his last three games. He has a 21.0-point high this season.

The game →
18Willie Rodriguez TEStarted
Kentucky at Missouri · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.7M

He now gets 29% of Kentucky's targets, up from 21%. For $5.7M, he has put up 14.7 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
19Giovanni Richardson WRStarted
Arizona at Kansas State · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:00 PM ET · $5.6M

30% of Arizona's targets now go to him, up from 6%. At $5.6M, he has scored 21.8 points a game over his last three games.

The game →
20Thomas Castellanos QBStarted
Texas Tech at Baylor · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $6.8M

Thomas Castellanos took over from Will Hammond in Week 9 and has averaged 34.8 points a game since. Hammond averaged 13.3 in his seven starts. He costs $6.8M and has averaged 34.8 points in his last three games. He has also run for 86 yards a game in that stretch, with 256 passing.

Read the preview →
21Micah Gilbert WRStarted
Notre Dame vs. SMU · Sat, Nov. 21 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.7M

His share of Notre Dame's targets is up to 22%, from 16%. For $5.7M, he has put up 20.2 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 30.8-point high this season.

The game →
22Javon Ross WRStarted
Tulsa vs. Charlotte · Sat, Nov. 21 · 2:00 PM ET · $5.7M

His targets rose to 6 a game, from 3.3, and he has scored 27 percent of Tulsa's receiving touchdowns, up from none. At $5.7M, he has scored 20.1 points a game over his last three games. He also faces the fifth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

The game →
23Jermane Hayes WRStarted
Memphis at Navy · Sat, Nov. 21 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.4M

He has scored 1 touchdown a game on 0.7 red-zone looks a game, up from 0.3 on 0.6, and his targets have come 15 yards downfield on average, up from 8.4. He costs $5.4M and has averaged 16.9 points in his last three games. He also faces the eighth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

Read the preview →
24Steven Robinson RBStarted
Southern Miss vs. South Alabama · Sat, Nov. 21 · 4:00 PM ET · $5.9M

His matchup: the 11th-worst defense against running backs in FBS. For $5.9M, he has put up 17.6 points a game across his last three games. He also gets 46% of Southern Miss' carries.

The game →
25Chase Sowell WRStarted
Penn State vs. Rutgers · Sat, Nov. 21 · 3:30 PM ET · $6.1M

He missed Week 9 injured; his targets rose to 10.5 a game, from 6.5, and he has had 50 percent of Penn State's receiving work inside the 20, up from 19. At $6.1M, he has scored 18.2 points a game over his last three games. He also faces the 13th-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

The game →

Built once for the week from each game's data: usage, production and the matchup. Players listed Doubtful or Out when it was built are left off. Status is RotoWire's, current when the page loads; a player listed Doubtful or Out since is greyed in his place. Games that have kicked off stay on the list, marked as started.