← CFB HubCaptain & Value picks

The Saturday Shortlist, Week 10

The week's 25 best captain options and 25 best values, ranked from each game's data, with links to the game previews.

25 captain picks · 25 value picks

One score for each player: his production (his last three games, his season and his two best games, with his role’s trend), adjusted for the defense he faces at his position, from 15 percent down against the toughest to 15 percent up against the softest, and 10 percent off for a Group of 6 player facing a Power 4 defense in the top half at his position. The projection only breaks ties.

1Easton Messer WRStarted
Florida Atlantic vs. UTSA · Thu, Nov. 5 · 7:30 PM ET · $14.9M

His 60.0-point game is the biggest on this list. He has averaged 47.7 points over his last three games, up from 30.1 for the season and got 34% of Florida Atlantic's targets while Dom Henry was out, up from 23%.

Read the preview →
2Jackson Gutierrez QBStarted
Navy vs. Temple · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:30 PM ET · $7.0M

He has run for 159 yards a game in his last three games, on top of 93 passing. He has also averaged 38.6 points in that stretch, up from 29.2 for the season and has a 50.1-point high this season.

Read the preview →
3Jesse Legree WRStarted
Oregon State vs. Texas State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 10:30 PM ET · $8.1M

He faces the fourth-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS. He has gone from 21% to 26% of Oregon State's targets.

Read the preview →
4Malachi Toney WRStarted
Miami at Notre Dame · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:30 PM ET · $16.3M

He has scored 2.3 touchdowns a game on 3.3 red-zone looks a game, up from 1.3 on 1.8, and his targets rose to 12.7 a game, from 9.8. He has also averaged 40.8 points over his last three games, up from 32.5 for the season and has a 53.4-point high this season. Miami hasn't faced a top-25 pass defense from a Power 4 school this season.

The game →
5Caleb Hawkins RBStarted
Oklahoma State at Kansas State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:00 PM ET · $14.6M

He has a 51.5-point game on his record this season. He has averaged 36.0 points in his last three games, up from 23.9 for the season and has gone from 57% to 65% of Oklahoma State's carries.

Read the preview →
6Nate Sheppard RBStarted
Duke at NC State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:30 PM ET · $13.0M

He has averaged 32.7 points across his last three games. He also has a 43.9-point high this season.

Read the preview →
7Jahiem White RBStarted
North Texas vs. Rice · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $12.9M

His share of North Texas' carries rose to 63% from 46%, all of it in games Brendon Haygood played only part of. He has a 42.0-point high this season.

Read the preview →
8Justin Stevenson WRStarted
North Texas vs. Rice · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $8.1M

With Corri Milliner out, he got 33% of North Texas' targets, up from 17%. He has also averaged 33.7 points in his last three games, up from 22.0 for the season and faces the 20th-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

Read the preview →
9Brad Jackson QBStarted
Texas State at Oregon State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 10:30 PM ET · $14.8M

34.4 points a game across his last three games, up from 27.1 for the season. He has a 48.6-point high this season.

Read the preview →
10Michael Hawkins QBStarted
West Virginia at Texas Tech · Sat, Nov. 7 · 9:30 PM ET · $9.6M

He has already put up 50.3 points in a game this season. He has also run for 87 yards a game over his last three games, with 254 passing.

Read the preview →
11Isaac Brown RBStarted
Louisville at Georgia Tech · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:30 PM ET · $13.3M

Louisville's running backs have scored 64 percent of its touchdowns, up from 29 percent. He faces the 12th-worst defense against running backs in FBS and has a 44.2-point high this season.

Read the preview →
12Cale Hellums QBStarted
Army vs. Air Force · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:30 PM ET · $12.2M

A quarterback who runs: 117 rushing yards and 35 passing yards a game across his last three games. He also has a 49.6-point high this season.

Read the preview →
13Dylan Riley RBStarted
Boise State at Colorado State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 6:00 PM ET · $12.9M

His work rose in games Sire Gaines missed or played only part of (Weeks 4, 5, 8 and 9), and it has held with Gaines back. He faces the worst defense against running backs in FBS.

Read the preview →
14Tayven Jackson QBStarted
North Texas vs. Rice · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $10.1M

He has thrown for 353 yards a game in his last three games. He has also averaged 30.8 points in that stretch, up from 24.5 for the season.

Read the preview →
16LaNorris Sellers QBStarted
South Carolina vs. Texas A&M · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:00 PM ET · $10.8M

Over his last three games, he has averaged 36.3 points, up from 27.3 for the season. He also has a 41.6-point high this season.

Read the preview →
17Lincoln Kienholz QBStarted
Louisville at Georgia Tech · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:30 PM ET · $8.6M

52 rushing yards a game in his last three games add to his 233 passing. He has a 37.5-point high this season.

Read the preview →
18Cole Tabb RBStarted
Cincinnati at Houston · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $6.4M

His work rose in games Gi'Bran Payne missed or played only part of (Weeks 7 and 8), and it has held with Payne back. He has also averaged 31.5 points across his last three games, up from 23.2 for the season.

Read the preview →
19Isaiah Myers WRStarted
Missouri State at Florida International · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $7.2M

Since Henry Belin replaced Skyler Locklear at quarterback, his targets rose to 9.3 a game, from 5, and Missouri State's receivers have scored all of its touchdowns in that span, after 50 percent before; his earlier numbers came in games Jmariyae Robinson missed or played only part of (Weeks 3 and 4); with both healthy, Robinson had 37 catches to his 29. He has a 47.2-point high this season.

Read the preview →
20Rasean Jones WRStarted
Boise State at Colorado State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 6:00 PM ET · $7.0M

He missed Week 6 injured; his targets rose to 8.7 a game, from 6.8, and he has had 47 percent of Boise State's receiving work inside the 20, up from 29. He also faces the worst pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
21Steven Robinson RBStarted
Southern Miss vs. James Madison · Thu, Nov. 5 · 8:00 PM ET · $5.9M

60% of Southern Miss' carries now go to him, up from 46%. He has averaged 27.2 points across his last three games, up from 19.7 for the season.

Read the preview →
22Jackson Harris WRStarted
LSU vs. Alabama · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:30 PM ET · $6.6M

He has had 36 percent of LSU's receiving work inside the 20, up from 6, and his targets rose to 9.3 a game, from 4.6. He has also averaged 29.4 points over his last three games, up from 18.4 for the season.

Read the preview →
23DeSean Bishop RBStarted
Tennessee vs. Kentucky · Sat, Nov. 7 · 6:15 PM ET · $13.2M

His share of Tennessee's carries is up to 69%, from 39%. He has a 40.0-point high this season.

Read the preview →
24Jeremiah Smith WRStarted
Ohio State vs. Oregon · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:30 PM ET · $16.6M

His season high is 57.7 points. He also faces the 15th-best pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
25Jamal Roberts RBStarted
Missouri vs. Texas · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:00 PM ET · $9.6M

This week he draws the fourth-best defense against running backs in FBS. He has a 45.0-point high this season and has gone from 62% to 75% of Missouri's carries.

The game →

Points for the price, measured against his position’s typical value, so a tight end is compared with tight ends. Players within about 10 percent of each other share a tier, and the softer matchup goes first inside it. $7.0M or under; at most six quarterbacks; the projection only breaks ties.

1Jackson Gutierrez QBStarted
Navy vs. Temple · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:30 PM ET · $7.0M

His 50.1-point game is the biggest on this list. At $7.0M, he has scored 38.6 points a game over his last three games. He has also run for 159 yards a game in that stretch, with 93 passing.

Read the preview →
2Jelani Thurman TEStarted
North Carolina at UConn · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.3M

At $5.3M, he has scored 16.0 points a game in his last three games. He also gets 23% of North Carolina's targets.

Read the preview →
3Cole Tabb RBStarted
Cincinnati at Houston · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $6.4M

His work rose in games Gi'Bran Payne missed or played only part of (Weeks 7 and 8), and it has held with Payne back. For $6.4M, he has put up 31.5 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
4Jackson Harris WRStarted
LSU vs. Alabama · Sat, Nov. 7 · 3:30 PM ET · $6.6M

He has had 36 percent of LSU's receiving work inside the 20, up from 6, and his targets rose to 9.3 a game, from 4.6. At $6.6M, he has scored 29.4 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 38.8-point high this season.

Read the preview →
5Kari Ashley TEStarted
TCU at Arizona · Fri, Nov. 6 · 10:15 PM ET · $5.3M

He has a 30.9-point game on his record this season. He costs $5.3M and has averaged 10.7 points in his last three games.

The game →
6Isaiah Mizell WRStarted
Arizona vs. TCU · Fri, Nov. 6 · 10:15 PM ET · $5.9M

His targets rose to 8 a game, from 4.8, and he has scored 1.3 touchdowns a game on 1 red-zone looks a game, up from 0.5 on 1. For $5.9M, he has put up 31.6 points a game across his last three games. He also faces the 12th-best pass defense in FBS. Arizona hasn't faced a top-25 pass defense from a Power 4 school this season.

The game →
7Patrick Overmyer TEStarted
Houston vs. Cincinnati · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $6.8M

He has scored 1.7 touchdowns a game on 3.3 red-zone looks a game, up from 0.4 on 1.8, and Houston's receivers have scored 82 percent of its touchdowns, up from 44 percent. At $6.8M, he has scored 18.5 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 40.4-point high this season.

Read the preview →
8Connor Lair TEStarted
Missouri State at Florida International · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $5.0M

Since Henry Belin replaced Skyler Locklear at quarterback, he has had 59 percent of Missouri State's receiving work inside the 20, up from 17, and his carries rose to 16 a game, from 4.5. He costs $5.0M and has averaged 16.5 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
9Steven Robinson RBStarted
Southern Miss vs. James Madison · Thu, Nov. 5 · 8:00 PM ET · $5.9M

His share of Southern Miss' carries is up to 60%, from 46%. For $5.9M, he has put up 27.2 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
10Luke Reynolds TEStarted
Virginia Tech at SMU · Fri, Nov. 6 · 7:00 PM ET · $6.5M

He has already put up 30.6 points in a game this season. At $6.5M, he has scored 12.4 points a game over his last three games. He also gets 24% of Virginia Tech's targets.

Read the preview →
11Andrew Rappleyea TEStarted
Penn State at Washington · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $4.8M

His targets rose to 10 a game, from 5, and he has scored 0.5 touchdowns a game on 1.5 red-zone looks a game, up from 0 on 0.5. He costs $4.8M and has averaged 14.7 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
12Koby Howard WRQuestionableStarted
Penn State at Washington · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $5.5M

22.3 points a game across his last three games, at a price of $5.5M. He also gets 20% of Penn State's targets.

The game →
13Umari Hatcher WRStarted
Syracuse vs. Clemson · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.8M

His season high is 45.2 points. At $6.8M, he has scored 24.7 points a game over his last three games. He also gets 31% of Syracuse's targets.

Read the preview →
14Willie Rodriguez TEStarted
Kentucky at Tennessee · Sat, Nov. 7 · 6:15 PM ET · $5.7M

He has scored 1.5 touchdowns a game on 2.5 red-zone looks a game, up from 0.2 on 1.4. He costs $5.7M and has averaged 16.0 points in his last three games. He also faces the eighth-best pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
15Chris Lawson WRStarted
Washington vs. Penn State · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $5.5M

He faces the 13th-best pass defense in FBS. For $5.5M, he has put up 24.4 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 33.5-point high this season.

The game →
16Kyle Koch WRStarted
North Texas vs. Rice · Sat, Nov. 7 · 4:00 PM ET · $5.4M

His targets rose to 8 a game, from 4.3, and he has had 31 percent of North Texas' receiving work inside the 20, up from 12. At $5.4M, he has scored 19.0 points a game over his last three games. He also faces the 20th-worst defense against wide receivers in FBS.

The game →
17Eric Olsen TEStarted
Oregon State vs. Texas State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 10:30 PM ET · $6.3M

He has a 27.5-point game on his record this season. He costs $6.3M and has averaged 12.4 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
18Braden Atkinson QBStarted
Oregon State vs. Texas State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 10:30 PM ET · $6.9M

He has already put up 39.7 points in a game this season. For $6.9M, he has put up 25.5 points a game across his last three games. He has also thrown for 376 yards a game in that stretch.

Read the preview →
19Clint Walker TEStarted
Buffalo at Miami (OH) · Tue, Nov. 3 · 8:00 PM ET · $5.4M

He has scored 1 touchdown a game on 1 red-zone looks a game, up from 0 on 0.3, and he has had 21 percent of Buffalo's receiving work inside the 20, up from 6. At $5.4M, he has scored 13.4 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 23.5-point high this season.

Read the preview →
20Gavin Freeman WRStarted
Baylor vs. Iowa State · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $6.2M

He gets 32% of Baylor's targets. He costs $6.2M and has averaged 19.4 points in his last three games. He also has a 33.4-point high this season.

Read the preview →
21RJ Vick WRStarted
Colorado State vs. Boise State · Sat, Nov. 7 · 6:00 PM ET · $5.4M

In games Jackson Harper played only part of, he got 25% of Colorado State's targets, up from 14%. For $5.4M, he has put up 15.9 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 31.5-point high this season.

Read the preview →
22Luke Gilbert TEStarted
Jacksonville State vs. Sam Houston · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:00 PM ET · $5.2M

His targets rose to 5.3 a game, from 1.6, and he has scored 0.7 touchdowns a game on 0.3 red-zone looks a game, up from 0.4 on 0.4. At $5.2M, he has scored 13.4 points a game over his last three games.

The game →
23Kyler Kasper WRStarted
BYU at Utah · Sat, Nov. 7 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.4M

25% of BYU's targets go to him. He costs $5.4M and has averaged 18.6 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
24Chase Sowell WRQuestionableStarted
Penn State at Washington · Sat, Nov. 7 · Time TBA · $5.9M

He got 27% of Penn State's targets in games Brett Eskildsen played only part of, up from 20%. For $5.9M, he has put up 21.1 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 32.1-point high this season.

The game →
25Cardae Mack RBStarted
Arizona State vs. Colorado · Sat, Nov. 7 · 7:30 PM ET · $6.2M

His carries rose to 24.5 a game, from 5.8, and he has had 100 percent of Arizona State's running-back work inside the 20, up from 33. At $6.2M, he has scored 25.3 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 41.6-point high this season.

Read the preview →

Built once for the week from each game's data: usage, production and the matchup. Players listed Doubtful or Out when it was built are left off. Status is RotoWire's, current when the page loads; a player listed Doubtful or Out since is greyed in his place. Games that have kicked off stay on the list, marked as started.