← CFB HubCaptain & Value picks

The Saturday Shortlist, Week 9

The week's 25 best captain options and 25 best values, ranked from each game's data, with links to the game previews.

25 captain picks · 25 value picks

One score for each player: his production (his last three games, his season and his two best games, with his role’s trend), adjusted for the defense he faces at his position, from 15 percent down against the toughest to 15 percent up against the softest, and 10 percent off for a Group of 6 player facing a Power 4 defense in the top half at his position. The projection only breaks ties.

1Easton Messer WRStarted
Florida Atlantic at North Texas · Thu, Oct. 29 · 7:30 PM ET · $14.7M

His 60.0-point game is the biggest on this list. He has averaged 36.3 points over his last three games, up from 26.9 for the season and got 32% of Florida Atlantic's targets while Dom Henry was out, up from 24%.

The game →
3Malachi Toney WRStarted
Miami at North Carolina · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:30 PM ET · $16.2M

His share of Miami's targets is up to 41%, from 29%. He has a 53.4-point high this season and has averaged 35.3 points across his last three games.

Read the preview →
4Jahiem White RBStarted
North Texas vs. Florida Atlantic · Thu, Oct. 29 · 7:30 PM ET · $12.7M

He now gets 63% of North Texas' carries, up from 38%. He has also averaged 30.8 points over his last three games and faces the 13th-worst defense against running backs in FBS.

Read the preview →
5Jamal Roberts RBStarted
Missouri at Arkansas · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:45 PM ET · $9.4M

76% of Missouri's carries now go to him, up from 61%. He has a 45.0-point high this season and has averaged 30.3 points in his last three games, up from 22.3 for the season.

Read the preview →
6Cale Hellums QBStarted
Army at Memphis · Sat, Oct. 31 · 8:00 PM ET · $12.2M

He has a 49.6-point game on his record this season. He has also run for 180 yards a game across his last three games, with 28 passing and has averaged 39.1 points in that stretch, up from 29.6 for the season.

Read the preview →
7Justin Stevenson WRStarted
North Texas vs. Florida Atlantic · Thu, Oct. 29 · 7:30 PM ET · $7.9M

His share of North Texas' targets rose to 28% from 18%, all of it while Corri Milliner was out. He has averaged 32.0 points over his last three games, up from 21.3 for the season.

Read the preview →
8Jackson Gutierrez QBStarted
Navy vs. Notre Dame · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.9M

He has already put up 50.1 points in a game this season. He has also run for 200 yards a game in his last three games, with 116 passing and has averaged 46.4 points in that stretch, up from 30.6 for the season. Navy hasn't faced a top-25 pass defense from a Power 4 school this season.

Read the preview →
9Gio Lopez QBStarted
Wake Forest vs. Virginia · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:45 PM ET · $7.9M

His season high is 45.4 points. He has averaged 36.1 points across his last three games, up from 29.3 for the season.

Read the preview →
10Jackson Arnold QBStarted
UNLV vs. Northern Illinois · Sat, Oct. 31 · 10:30 PM ET · $10.6M

He faces the seventh-worst pass defense in FBS. He has also run for 83 yards a game over his last three games, with 167 passing.

Read the preview →
12Nate Sheppard RBStarted
Duke vs. Boston College · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $12.8M

He now gets 75% of Duke's carries, up from 55%. He has also averaged 30.7 points across his last three games. Duke hasn't faced a top-25 run defense from a Power 4 school this season.

Read the preview →
14Lincoln Kienholz QBStarted
Louisville vs. Stanford · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:15 PM ET · $8.3M

His matchup: the 19th-worst pass defense in FBS. He has also run for 39 yards a game in his last three games, with 235 passing.

Read the preview →
15Ashton Daniels QBStarted
Florida State vs. Clemson · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:00 PM ET · $8.1M

He faces the 13th-best pass defense in FBS. He has a 48.9-point high this season and has averaged 36.3 points across his last three games, up from 28.2 for the season.

Read the preview →
16Micah Ford RBStarted
Stanford at Louisville · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:15 PM ET · $6.2M

He has a 52.1-point game on his record this season. He has also gone from 54% to 65% of Stanford's carries.

Read the preview →
17Jeremiah Smith WRStarted
Ohio State at USC · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:30 PM ET · $16.5M

He has already put up 57.7 points in a game this season. He gets 36% of Ohio State's targets.

Read the preview →
18Isaiah Myers WRStarted
Missouri State vs. Sam Houston · Tue, Oct. 27 · 8:00 PM ET · $7.2M

His season high is 47.2 points. He has also averaged 32.1 points across his last three games, up from 24.1 for the season.

The game →
19Umari Hatcher WRStarted
Syracuse vs. SMU · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.8M

He gets 35% of Syracuse's targets. He has a 45.2-point high this season.

Read the preview →
20Steven Robinson RBStarted
Southern Miss at UL Monroe · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.7M

This week he draws the 11th-worst defense against running backs in FBS. He also gets 53% of Southern Miss' carries.

Read the preview →
21Wayne Harris WRStarted
Kent State at Sacramento State · Fri, Oct. 30 · 10:30 PM ET · $7.0M

He got 36% of Kent State's targets in games Da'Realyst Clark played only part of, up from 20%. He faces the fifth-worst pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
23Wayshawn Parker RBStarted
Utah at Cincinnati · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:45 PM ET · $9.8M

He has already put up 46.9 points in a game this season. He has gone from 34% to 45% of Utah's carries.

Read the preview →
25Mario Sanders WRStarted
Southern Miss at UL Monroe · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $8.0M

His matchup: the 10th-worst pass defense in FBS. He got 29% of Southern Miss' targets in games A.J. Little missed or played only part of, up from 23%.

Read the preview →

Points for the price, measured against his position’s typical value, so a tight end is compared with tight ends. Players within about 10 percent of each other share a tier, and the softer matchup goes first inside it. $7.0M or under; at most six quarterbacks; the projection only breaks ties.

1Kari Ashley TEStarted
TCU vs. Kansas · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.3M

$5.3M for 15.7 points a game over his last three games. He has a 30.9-point high this season.

Read the preview →
2Umari Hatcher WRStarted
Syracuse vs. SMU · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.8M

At $6.8M, he has scored 29.4 points a game in his last three games. He also has a 45.2-point high this season and gets 35% of Syracuse's targets.

Read the preview →
3Jackson Gutierrez QBStarted
Navy vs. Notre Dame · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.9M

He has run for 200 yards a game across his last three games, on top of 116 passing. For $6.9M, he has put up 46.4 points a game in that stretch. He also has a 50.1-point high this season. Navy hasn't faced a top-25 pass defense from a Power 4 school this season.

Read the preview →
4Koby Howard WRQuestionableStarted
Penn State vs. Purdue · Sat, Oct. 31 · 4:15 PM ET · $5.5M

$5.5M for 22.3 points a game over his last three games. He also gets 20% of Penn State's targets.

The game →
5Micah Ford RBStarted
Stanford at Louisville · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:15 PM ET · $6.2M

His 52.1-point game is the biggest on this list. He costs $6.2M and has averaged 27.3 points in his last three games. He has also gone from 54% to 65% of Stanford's carries.

Read the preview →
6Isaiah Mizell WRStarted
Arizona at Texas Tech · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $5.5M

24.8 points a game across his last three games, at a price of $5.5M. He has also gone from 11% to 23% of Arizona's targets.

Read the preview →
7Daunte Bacheyie TEStarted
Syracuse vs. SMU · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $4.8M

$4.8M for 11.6 points a game over his last three games. He got 16% of Syracuse's targets in games Justus Ross-Simmons missed or played only part of, up from 8%.

Read the preview →
8Jelani Thurman TEStarted
North Carolina vs. Miami · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.1M

At $5.1M, he has scored 12.9 points a game in his last three games. He also gets 29% of North Carolina's targets.

Read the preview →
9Cole Tabb RBStarted
Cincinnati vs. Utah · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:45 PM ET · $6.3M

His share of Cincinnati's carries rose to 35% from 17%, all of it in games Gi'Bran Payne missed or played only part of. For $6.3M, he has put up 26.9 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
10Steven Robinson RBStarted
Southern Miss at UL Monroe · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.7M

He faces the 11th-worst defense against running backs in FBS. At $5.7M, he has scored 22.7 points a game over his last three games. He also gets 53% of Southern Miss' carries.

Read the preview →
11Wayne Harris WRStarted
Kent State at Sacramento State · Fri, Oct. 30 · 10:30 PM ET · $7.0M

This week he draws the fifth-worst pass defense in FBS. He costs $7.0M and has averaged 25.4 points in his last three games. He got 36% of Kent State's targets in games Da'Realyst Clark played only part of, up from 20%.

Read the preview →
12Andrew Rappleyea TEStarted
Penn State vs. Purdue · Sat, Oct. 31 · 4:15 PM ET · $4.7M

He now gets 24% of Penn State's targets, up from 9%. For $4.7M, he has put up 12.8 points a game across his last three games. He also faces the 13th-worst pass defense in FBS.

Read the preview →
13Jordan Allen WRStarted
Georgia Tech at Pittsburgh · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.3M

He got 28% of Georgia Tech's targets in games Kevin Roche played only part of, up from 18%. At $5.3M, he has scored 20.1 points a game over his last three games.

Read the preview →
14Cataurus Hicks WRStarted
Pittsburgh vs. Georgia Tech · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:30 PM ET · $5.6M

His share of Pittsburgh's targets is up to 27%, from 18%. He costs $5.6M and has averaged 20.5 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
15Legend Glasker WRStarted
BYU vs. Arizona State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.5M

He has a 29.1-point game on his record this season. For $5.5M, he has put up 16.9 points a game across his last three games. He also gets 20% of BYU's targets.

Read the preview →
16RJ Vick WRQuestionableStarted
Colorado State at Utah State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $5.4M

With Jackson Harper out, he got 20% of Colorado State's targets, up from 11%. At $5.4M, he has scored 18.2 points a game over his last three games.

The game →
17Fame Ijeboi RBStarted
Purdue at Penn State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 4:15 PM ET · $6.1M

60% of Purdue's carries now go to him, up from 49%. He costs $6.1M and has averaged 20.3 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
18Justin Bowick WRStarted
Oklahoma State at Iowa State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:00 PM ET · $6.3M

He has already put up 38.8 points in a game this season. For $6.3M, he has put up 19.4 points a game across his last three games. He also gets 21% of Oklahoma State's targets.

The game →
19Collin Dixon WRStarted
Illinois at Maryland · Sat, Oct. 31 · 12:00 PM ET · $6.8M

His season high is 45.6 points. At $6.8M, he has scored 22.3 points a game over his last three games. He also gets 35% of Illinois' targets.

Read the preview →
20Connor Lair TEStarted
Missouri State vs. Sam Houston · Tue, Oct. 27 · 8:00 PM ET · $4.9M

He has a 24.6-point game on his record this season. He costs $4.9M and has averaged 14.1 points in his last three games.

Read the preview →
21Braden Atkinson QBStarted
Oregon State at Fresno State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 11:00 PM ET · $6.9M

He has already put up 39.7 points in a game this season. For $6.9M, he has put up 33.2 points a game across his last three games.

Read the preview →
23Kwazi Gilmer WRStarted
Nebraska vs. Washington · Sat, Oct. 31 · 8:00 PM ET · $6.4M

He has a 37.7-point game on his record this season. He costs $6.4M and has averaged 21.1 points in his last three games. He got 31% of Nebraska's targets in games Jacory Barney played only part of, up from 24%.

Read the preview →
24Aiden Flora RBStarted
Iowa State vs. Oklahoma State · Sat, Oct. 31 · 7:00 PM ET · $6.2M

His share of Iowa State's carries is up to 49%, from 35%. For $6.2M, he has put up 22.6 points a game across his last three games. He also has a 49.1-point high this season.

Read the preview →
25Cardae Mack RBStarted
Arizona State at BYU · Sat, Oct. 31 · 3:30 PM ET · $6.0M

In games Kyson Brown played only part of, he got 48% of Arizona State's carries, up from 10%. At $6.0M, he has scored 27.4 points a game over his last three games. He also has a 41.6-point high this season.

Read the preview →

Built once for the week from each game's data: usage, production and the matchup. Players listed Doubtful or Out when it was built are left off. Status is RotoWire's, current when the page loads; a player listed Doubtful or Out since is greyed in his place. Games that have kicked off stay on the list, marked as started.